Clark County Seat · Central Ohio

Insurance in Springfield, Ohio

Springfield residents deserve an independent agent who shops multiple carriers — not a captive selling you one company’s rates. We give you options.

More than one company’s rates.

Springfield is the county seat of Clark County and one of the larger cities in west-central Ohio, with a population around 58,000. It has a mix of long-established neighborhoods, an active downtown, and Wittenberg University anchoring the east side. The city carries a strong manufacturing heritage — International Harvester ran a major plant here for decades — and the economy today blends manufacturing, healthcare, education, and small business.

Here is why an independent agency matters in a city like Springfield. The captive agents — State Farm, Allstate, the names on every corner — can only offer you the rates of the one company they represent. When that company raises your premium or tightens its terms, your agent has nowhere else to take you. We are independent, which means we shop your coverage across multiple carriers and put the real options in front of you. Laramie grew up nearby in Clark County, so this is not a distant market to us.

On the commercial side, Springfield generates steady demand — contractors, light manufacturing, retail, and service businesses that need general liability, commercial auto, property, and workers’ comp written correctly. We handle these every day for businesses across the region, and we know how to structure coverage that holds up.

Homeowners coverage in Springfield runs the full range of ages and styles, and a lot of the housing stock predates 1970. Some carriers write older homes cleanly; others bury exclusions in the fine print. Because we shop multiple carriers, we can steer you to the one that fits your property instead of forcing your home into a policy that was not built for it.

Options, not just one quote.

38 Monument Square, Urbana

Springfield insurance questions, answered.

Why would a Springfield resident use Sellman Insurance in Urbana instead of a local Springfield agency?

+

Fair question. We’re 25 minutes away and we handle most of our Springfield clients by phone. The reason they stay is the same reason our Urbana clients stay — we shop multiple carriers and give you options. Most captive agencies in Springfield can only quote you one company.

Do you write commercial insurance for Springfield businesses?

+

Yes. We work with contractors, retailers, and light industrial businesses in Springfield on general liability, commercial auto, workers’ comp, and bonds. Ty Finkbine, our Commercial Lines Manager, specializes in this.

Can you insure an older home in Springfield?

+

Yes. Springfield has a lot of homes built before 1970, and some carriers are better suited for these than others. We know which ones write older homes cleanly and which ones add exclusions. We’ll steer you toward the right carrier for your property.

Do you write life insurance for Springfield residents?

+

Yes. We write term and whole life policies for Springfield families and business owners. Key-person insurance is also common for small business owners in the area.

How do I get a quote if I’m in Springfield?

+

Fill out the form on this site or call (937) 653-1360. We’ll contact you the same day. You can also visit our office at 38 Monument Square in Urbana — about 25 minutes from Springfield on US-36.

See what options you’ve been missing, Springfield.

One independent agent, multiple carriers, and a same-day callback — instead of one company’s rates.